Jack Zipes and fairy tales
I’ve been perusing three of Jack Zipes’ books, Breaking the Magic Spell, When Dreams Came True, and Fairy Tale as Myth…and he claims that fairy tales are intrinsically marxist in method. I really don’t agree. I concur that there are some that can be read that way, and it fits, but when you describe others(like Faithful John) as “the protagonist simply improves his position in regard to material wealth and power. He seizes the opportunity to succeed, as do the princesses and fair young maidens of the peasant class.”(pg 155, Breaking the Magic Spell)
Whawhawhaaaat? Now, if you’ve READ Faithful John, the protagonist(FAITHFUL F’ING JOHN!!!) doesn’t really seize the oppurtunity to succeed. he’s already the king’s right hand man, and in fact operates completely on that level in order to help the king succeed and to protect the King’s new bride. In return, he’s threatened with the death penalty and turned to stone. Yep. Sure can see the protagonist just improving his position of wealth and power!
The other tales that Zipes claims operate this way are ‘The Brave Little Tailor’, ‘The White Snake’ and ‘Puss in Boots’. It seems Zipes main gripe with these tales are the fact that, instead of working for some higher cause(???) they seek to improve their own life.
um. I don’t know what to say about that, and only hope in further reading to prove this wrong, and poorly analyzed.